Lonelygirl15

First off, excellent analysis SharpI. Second, Jay, I think that your beef with the story runs deep enough where it's no longer constructive criticism--it's almost irrelevant.


But this seems to be where you've lost sight of 1) what your show is and 2) what we're talking about.

You seem to have ...

Thanks so much! This and the quick reply are great new features.

I would disagree with the idea that Gemma represents fan research. On the contrary I think that she is pretty close to who she claims to be--a defected Order member who sees what is happening to Bree, feels, compassion because her situation is not so different, and wants to help.

The reason why ...

Ditto on what Ralph the Dog said.

Thought you all might be interested:

http://www.lonelygirl15.com/lgpedia/ind ... ing_device

I find site navigation a bit clumsy--here are a few suggestions:

1. Moving through pages in long threads is currently tedious. To go to page 112 of a 250 page thread, one must cycle through some 108 pages to get there. Would it be possible to incorporate a "jump to page X" button/link?

2. The ...

Daniel mimicks this gesture, oddly, right near the beginning of 0087 Jonas?

Is Daniel mocking Jonas? Or are the Creators mocking us for complaining that the characters all use the same facial expressions & gestures? Or is this some sort of weird code?

This question's been bothering me more than it ...

As long as this discussion is still continuing...

There is some value to having two separate "forums" for discussion in that we avoid the cognitive bias of groupthink. The speculative discussions on the comments and forums tend to take divergent paths and this makes for really interesting dialogue ...

Neither--they should go to friends or family. Going to Jonas' house would be setting a bad example to all of LG15 fandom; people should not go to stay at strangers' houses that they meet on the internet, offering help.

You know, I think we might be starting to see some development. Bree is beginning to act a little more mature. And she explained why she's been carrying on as she has. If we get her explaining it this vid, maybe we'll have her getting beyond it in the next one. Maybe.


Maybe, but what came out ...

Hope I don't get jumped on like trainer was at first...

I feel a little insulted. I don't think I "jumped on" anyone. I just tried to explain why I thought the comments section was valuable and why I wouldn't like it to be "eliminated." Next time I'll save my thoughts for the video comments ...

This show is awful at introducing new characters. They get no heralds. They get no build-up. We have endless people speculating about the mysterious phantom "cassia" yet we are expected to care about these two who come out of nowhere? Jonas doesn't even have any ties to the canon of the series, he ...

Not obvious to me apparently

Thanks

I've noticed that it takes a long time for private messages to clear my outbox. Why is this?

I don't understand. When someone makes a good point, someone else goes and adds it somewhere into the LGPedia? Wouldn't it make more sense for people to post things on a similar topic in a similar place (like the forums)?

I think it makes more sense, once a topic has been talked out in either the ...

I don't think I could agree any less with what's been said in this thread. Except, that is, for the suggested ignore feature, that would be nice as there are some contributors who only post hurtful & unproductive comments.

I wouldn't mind the complete elimination of the comments section to ...