Could Jonas and Bree be siblings?

Post by **Broken Kid** » Sat Jan 06, 2007 5:14 pm

There's been a lot of discussion about this in the video thread and many comparisons to Star Wars. Let's discuss it here!

sweetie55 · Post by **sweetie55** » Sat Jan 06, 2007 5:20 pm

It's possible that they are, but it kind of feels.....overdone. I do think however Jonas knows more than he's letting on. I mean, why would he question Daniel over and over if the guy Bree was walking with in "The Unthinkable Happened" was indeed her dad. Foreshadowing.... Also he hid his face quite a bit when that truck passed by them while in the parking garage, as if he knew who they were. I dunno. Just blabbing now.

BrokenBliss · Post by **BrokenBliss** » Sat Jan 06, 2007 5:23 pm

Wait, what? So would Bree be related to Jonas' and his missing parents, or is Jonas related to the parents that Bree never knew?
So then who are these substitutes?

generalization · Post by **generalization** » Sat Jan 06, 2007 5:24 pm

sweetie55 wrote:Also he hid his face quite a bit when that truck passed by them while in the parking garage, as if he knew who they were. I dunno. Just blabbing now.

I noticed that as well. But never said anything about it. I thought at the time I saw that though (and I'm not big into conspiracy theories. I just watch and see how the story folds out) that he was more afraid of someone noticing that the same people had been following them. Not necessarily that they would know HIM. You know, just generally trying to hide...while being in a car... yeah.
But of course, it makes for a better story if he actually knew them or whatever.

Oh, and for what it's worth, I'm cool with Jonas now... I was one of the original 'Ew, I don't see what everyone likes about him' people. But as his character has grown I've grown to like him more. But not in the "Omg he's sooo sexy" way.

GoodGollyItsHolly · Post by **GoodGollyItsHolly** » Sat Jan 06, 2007 7:13 pm

I dont think so. I think that Jonas' parents are around, somewhere. I think that Bree was the child of parents who were sacraficed. hahah

Honestly though, The fact that Jonas kept saying "are you sure thats her dad" Makes me wonder if Jonas knows who her real dad is.

After gemma we know not to trust anyone.

HazelButtercup · Post by **HazelButtercup** » Sat Jan 06, 2007 8:34 pm

In the video thread of "My Dad Said...", it's funny to see the opinions about the possibility of Bree and Jonas being siblings: "lame", "stupid", "far-fetched".

I think it would be GREAT! I think they have both helped Bree and it would be nice to have them both in her life on her side.

Sammy214 · Post by **Sammy214** » Sat Jan 06, 2007 10:56 pm

I think that maybe possible. I mean, in the recent video, Bree's dad tells her he and her mother are not her real parents. Jonas' parents are missing...maybe... Or maybe her real parents just got killed by the Order but...we'll have to find out in the future videos!

Skunkwaffle · Post by **Skunkwaffle** » Sun Jan 07, 2007 11:25 pm

GoodGollyItsHolly wrote:Honestly though, The fact that Jonas kept saying "are you sure thats her dad" Makes me wonder if Jonas knows who her real dad is.

If that's true though, it sounds like Jonas was expecting to see her real dad turn up, so maybe he's not as informed as we think. I do think he knows more than he's let on though.

onetruegnome · Post by **onetruegnome** » Mon Jan 08, 2007 12:24 am

Skunkwaffle wrote:
GoodGollyItsHolly wrote:Honestly though, The fact that Jonas kept saying "are you sure thats her dad" Makes me wonder if Jonas knows who her real dad is.
If that's true though, it sounds like Jonas was expecting to see her real dad turn up, so maybe he's not as informed as we think. I do think he knows more than he's let on though.

I just think he said "are you sure that's her real dad" because he's just reminding us of what we noticed before - her parents look too young to be her parents and it turns out they weren't her real parents.

Beckers · Post by **Beckers** » Mon Jan 08, 2007 12:30 am

Bree and Jonas being siblings seems like the most obvious answer which makes me think that it won't end up being so.

livelongandprosper77 · Mon Jan 08, 2007 1:06 am

Hmm Jonas as Luke Skywalker urr umm maybe i guess, but yeah this line of thinking tends to be a little obvious. You would think with as many twists that have happened that the creators will come up with something totally 180 degrees different and unique.

alex · Post by **alex** » Mon Jan 08, 2007 1:31 am

livelongandprosper77 wrote:Hmm Jonas as Luke Skywalker urr umm maybe i guess, but yeah this line of thinking tends to be a little obvious. You would think with as many twists that have happened that the creators will come up with something totally 180 degrees different and unique.

agreed. it would be so easy and boring to be like "OH THEY'RE RELATED"

yoruba · Post by **yoruba** » Mon Jan 08, 2007 1:36 am

Honestly though, The fact that Jonas kept saying "are you sure thats her dad" Makes me wonder if Jonas knows who her real dad is.

Either that, or he knew or recognized her adoptive father. Both could be possible.

gigglingmonk · Post by **gigglingmonk** » Mon Jan 08, 2007 2:39 am

I don't think they're related..it just seems.......too simple. I mean, maybe I'm giving them too much credit, but I think the creators would want to do something that isn't so easy to guess at. True, eventually someone would guess what the plot actually is, but this has been brought up repeatedly, and I don't think the creators would want to do something thats so easy to go "OMG, this is what I think they're doing!!!!!"

AniDonia · Post by **AniDonia** » Mon Jan 08, 2007 5:50 am

onetruegnome wrote: I just think he said "are you sure that's her real dad" because he's just reminding us of what we noticed before - her parents look too young to be her parents and it turns out they weren't her real parents.

I think that's a great observation.

And I think it would be lame and farfetched if Jonas and Bree *just happened* to be siblings. Just cause they both have a "missing parents" thing going on. You know, Bree and Jonas have just as much chance of being siblings as Bree and Daniel. Why hasn't anyone brought up that? Maybe Daniel's parents don't care much about him because his little sister was secretly kidnapped from the hospital and then declared stillborn and they've never recovered! And all that romantic tension between them is OMG! INCEST!!!

Or MAYBE, Daniel was adopted too, and his parents don't give a shit because he was some baby plopped on their doorstep that the Order said "here, go raise or we kill you" and his REAL parents are really JONAS' parents so they are siblings! Or hey, they are about the same age so they can be long-lost TWINS! Or how about Bree and Daniel and Jonas secretly share the SAME parents...

I think I've made my point now.