Could Jonas and Bree be siblings?

AniDonia · Post by **AniDonia** » Mon Jan 08, 2007 10:53 pm

kristin wrote:I do think some of the arguments for Jonas and Bree being siblings are compelling.

I first starting thinking about it when she moved into his house, before Daniel came there, and there was absolutely no hint of romantic connection. Sure, not every male-female pair of teens is going to start going at it when the adults leave the room, but these are incredibly good looking people stuck out in the middle of nowhere together with no better way to pass the time -- yet zilch for sex or romance.

Um... you do know that there is pretty much nothing genetic that keeps us from being attracted to blood relatives, right? It's socialization that does the trick. In other words, if someone was secretly your brother and neither of you knew, there really isn't any "magical DNA recognition" that would keep the two of you from banging each other.

Kasdeja · Post by **Kasdeja** » Tue Jan 09, 2007 10:30 am

Don't you think Jonas would remember his mom being pregnant?

nobackspacebutton · Post by **nobackspacebutton** » Tue Jan 09, 2007 12:03 pm

Its possible they could be related by the idea that neither of their parents are their real parents?

Jonas' "parents" disappeared. Perhaps his 'parents' were not his real birth parents.

He could still have the same birth mother as Bree did.

Kasdeja · Post by **Kasdeja** » Tue Jan 09, 2007 12:35 pm

Yeah..dunno...seems kinda far fetched...but who knows. I mean, can you imagine how long it would take to tell THAT story in Bree-nese?

nobackspacebutton · Post by **nobackspacebutton** » Tue Jan 09, 2007 12:37 pm

Kasdeja wrote:Yeah..dunno...seems kinda far fetched...but who knows. I mean, can you imagine how long it would take to tell THAT story in Bree-nese?

"sooooo....jonas' mom was my mom....buttttttt......we didn't know each other......i guess when i was born.....jonas had already been shipped off to california to some other people....whooo he thought was his real parents...."

Kasdeja · Post by **Kasdeja** » Tue Jan 09, 2007 12:48 pm

spaced out over 15 videos

Luv2Skydive · Post by **Luv2Skydive** » Tue Jan 09, 2007 1:11 pm

The only connection I can (maybe) see is both sets of parents "disappeared" when the kids were (about) the same age? I think Jonas' parents left 6 years ago, so if he was 16 when they left he'd be 22 now, and Bree's parents left when she was 16. I could be wrong on all counts.

nobackspacebutton · Post by **nobackspacebutton** » Tue Jan 09, 2007 1:43 pm

Jonas' YT account says that he is 19. If his parents disappeared 6 yrs ago then he would have been 13.

kristin · Post by **kristin** » Tue Jan 09, 2007 4:29 pm

AniDonia wrote:
kristin wrote:I do think some of the arguments for Jonas and Bree being siblings are compelling.

I first starting thinking about it when she moved into his house, before Daniel came there, and there was absolutely no hint of romantic connection. Sure, not every male-female pair of teens is going to start going at it when the adults leave the room, but these are incredibly good looking people stuck out in the middle of nowhere together with no better way to pass the time -- yet zilch for sex or romance.
Um... you do know that there is pretty much nothing genetic that keeps us from being attracted to blood relatives, right? It's socialization that does the trick. In other words, if someone was secretly your brother and neither of you knew, there really isn't any "magical DNA recognition" that would keep the two of you from banging each other.

I realize that socialization is the reason brothers and sisters tend not to become sexually involved. However, if the Creators are planning to unveil a sibling relationship between them, it'd be a bit over-the-top and unnecessarily icky for them to have a sexual affair precede the revelation.

kayokosaeki · Post by **kayokosaeki** » Wed Jan 10, 2007 7:42 pm

GoodGollyItsHolly wrote:Honestly though, The fact that Jonas kept saying "are you sure thats her dad" Makes me wonder if Jonas knows who her real dad is.

or as if saying "are you sure that's her dad? they dont look related at all"

a precursor to what we later learn.....that bree didn't grow up with her real parents....

milowent · Post by **milowent** » Wed Jan 10, 2007 7:48 pm

kayokosaeki wrote:
GoodGollyItsHolly wrote:Honestly though, The fact that Jonas kept saying "are you sure thats her dad" Makes me wonder if Jonas knows who her real dad is.
or as if saying "are you sure that's her dad? they dont look related at all"

hmmm. Or as if he actually knew what bree's dad looks like (i.e., his dad). if jonas knew they were siblings already, it would explain his odd sudden fascination with lg15, to the point of inviting this random stranger on youtube to live with him. he's a lonely guy who lost his parents, wouldn't he want to connect with his sister.

nobackspacebutton · Post by **nobackspacebutton** » Thu Jan 11, 2007 8:13 am

They aren't gay. The storyline wouldn't work out like that. It just wouldn't.

Public majority wouldn't go for it.

Daniel will end up with Bree. As it was always meant to be.

milowent · Post by **milowent** » Thu Jan 11, 2007 9:46 am

nobackspacebutton wrote:They aren't gay. The storyline wouldn't work out like that. It just wouldn't.

I have to agree. While it could be an interesting and deep storyline to pursue, lg15 is not going to visit brokeback mountain. I bet we get a few more ambiguous clues of it here and there, just to keep us guessing. I guess Jonas could end up being gay, i think the world can handle that.

nobackspacebutton wrote:Daniel will end up with Bree. As it was always meant to be.

It it was meant to be, even the Creators claim they didn't intend that. I have my doubts about that claim, but there it is.

nobackspacebutton · Post by **nobackspacebutton** » Thu Jan 11, 2007 9:53 am

milowent wrote:
nobackspacebutton wrote:They aren't gay. The storyline wouldn't work out like that. It just wouldn't.
I have to agree. While it could be an interesting and deep storyline to pursue, lg15 is not going to visit brokeback mountain. I bet we get a few more ambiguous clues of it here and there, just to keep us guessing. I guess Jonas could end up being gay, i think the world can handle that.

Definately agreeing with you there. Jonas is the odd one right now.

Beckers · Post by **Beckers** » Thu Jan 11, 2007 1:45 pm

Maybe Jonas said he bet kisses like a dead fish because he isn't attracted to her at all....meaning, maybe they ARE siblings.