Could Jonas and Bree be siblings?

Taig · Post by **Taig** » Thu Jan 11, 2007 3:53 pm

nobackspacebutton wrote:
They aren't gay. The storyline wouldn't work out like that. It just wouldn't.

Wouldn't work out that way? Or Shouldn't ?

Kasdeja · Post by **Kasdeja** » Thu Jan 11, 2007 3:55 pm

I won't say wouldn't or shouldn't, just improbable.

French Rocket · Post by **French Rocket** » Sat Jan 13, 2007 6:36 pm

GoodGollyItsHolly wrote:

Honestly though, The fact that Jonas kept saying "are you sure thats her dad" Makes me wonder if Jonas knows who her real dad is.

It could be his dad. That's why. Or he just had a strong likeness to his dad.

JustAnotherLonelyGirl. · Sun Jan 14, 2007 2:30 pm

What if, rather than being related, Jonas is just another "order baby" ?

Taig · Post by **Taig** » Sun Jan 14, 2007 6:30 pm

for those looking for the the conversation that evolved from the original thread...you may find it at

"Could Bree and the Others be Aliens or Some Other Sort of Creature?"

http://www.lonelygirl15.com/forum/viewt ... sc&start=0

BlueEyes · Post by **BlueEyes** » Sun Jan 14, 2007 9:29 pm

Even though I don't believe that Jonas could be Bree's brother, it could happen.

Like in Bree's recent video, at the end she says "I'm completely alone." maybe that could be a foreshadowing of her finding out that she's not alone (family wise I mean, she'll always have Daniel and all)

I don't know, it was a silly thought I had.

nobackspacebutton · Post by **nobackspacebutton** » Mon Jan 15, 2007 8:05 am

BlueEyes wrote:Even though I don't believe that Jonas could be Bree's brother, it could happen.

Like in Bree's recent video, at the end she says "I'm completely alone." maybe that could be a foreshadowing of her finding out that she's not alone (family wise I mean, she'll always have Daniel and all)

I don't know, it was a silly thought I had.

Definately not a silly thought...I agree with you that it could be a forshadowing...either for Jonas to be related to her (Bree find more family) or Bree coming together with Jonas and Daniel and they becoming "family".

Luv2Skydive · Post by **Luv2Skydive** » Mon Jan 15, 2007 10:34 am

BlueEyes wrote:Even though I don't believe that Jonas could be Bree's brother, it could happen.

Like in Bree's recent video, at the end she says "I'm completely alone." maybe that could be a foreshadowing of her finding out that she's not alone (family wise I mean, she'll always have Daniel and all)

I don't know, it was a silly thought I had.

It could also be a foreshadowing to Bree's other alter, Cassie, and who knows how many other alters she could have in that wacky head of hers. The "lazy eye" reference might be a metaphor. She says when she was 4 she learned to see the world from a completely different point of view and that the correction of the lazy eye was done by putting a monkey into a cage. We can interpret that a few ways....I have a feeling she is no where near alone inside...she just doesn't realize it yet.

Pi · Post by Pi » Mon Jan 15, 2007 12:44 pm

nobackspacebutton wrote:
BlueEyes wrote:Even though I don't believe that Jonas could be Bree's brother, it could happen.

Like in Bree's recent video, at the end she says "I'm completely alone." maybe that could be a foreshadowing of her finding out that she's not alone (family wise I mean, she'll always have Daniel and all)

I don't know, it was a silly thought I had.

Definately not a silly thought...I agree with you that it could be a forshadowing...either for Jonas to be related to her (Bree find more family) or Bree coming together with Jonas and Daniel and they becoming "family".

I agree it's not a silly thought. Bree keeps feeling alien-ated and alone. But, why? I mean all around her people are there for her making 'sacrifices.' Lucy talked about it in regards to the ceremony. Daniel likes to remind her of his sacrifices and Jonas reminded us how DB didn't hesitate to save Bree. Then good ole Dad made the ultimate sacrifice. They're behavior suggests there's a bond or a connection there and yet she appears not to see it. Will Bree ever sacrifice her own ego long enough to feel and actively be apart of something? Will she ever be food for others or what?

As for Jonas, entering the picture. I don't know that it means he has to be a closely related blood brother. Yeah, it's possible but it seems like it would be to easy and solve her alienation problem to quickly at this point. If Jonas was blood related he'd just have to betray her. I mean, just because you're related by blood it doesn't mean you have instant identity, are close and everything is hunky dory. Major lesson there. With the death of Bree's Dad there's something of that lesson as well. They're not blood related, but he sacrificed himself for her anyways. Beautiful stuff...Dad got it and Jonas...(shrugs) has his doubts and his own issues.

(Altho, I think this is surface stuff and don't belive Dad physically died. Most days I think Bree has been to up to something from the very beginning...heh)

Pi

redheaddiva · Post by **redheaddiva** » Mon Jan 15, 2007 2:42 pm

milowent wrote:
nobackspacebutton wrote:They aren't gay. The storyline wouldn't work out like that. It just wouldn't.
I have to agree. While it could be an interesting and deep storyline to pursue, lg15 is not going to visit brokeback mountain. I bet we get a few more ambiguous clues of it here and there, just to keep us guessing. I guess Jonas could end up being gay, i think the world can handle that.

What I find really interesting is that so many people are saying "Hey, Jonas must be gay" because:

1. Jonas isn't humping Bree's leg.
2. Jonas and Daniel are becoming friends.

Seriously, is heterosexuality so fragile?

As someone who would be the first in line to read Jonas/Daniel slash fiction, I have to admit that I don't think the Creatorsauruses are writing Jonas as a gay or bi character. I think that either he's not interested in Bree because he's just not (I know that I'm not attracted to every single attractive guy I see/know), or he's attracted to Bree but not about to be so slimy as to weasel his way in between her and Daniel. That "cold fish" remark was either sour grapes or an effort to get Daniel to deny it by producing a good ol' male-bonding kiss-and-tell story.

Or, he could be a good-guy Watcher just doing his job of watching Bree & Daniel... from inside his own mansion. Teach a girl to skate, play some foosball with the guy that's crushing on her, do some vlogs to show that they're alive and well... all in a day's work, you know?

JustAnotherLonelyGirl. · Mon Jan 15, 2007 2:49 pm

I agree with redheaddiva.

And I also thought of the alterego Cassie theory, like Luv2SkyDive. The "I'm completely alone" statement was said with such emphasis, it must mean something. I tried to think of what and that idea popped into my head. Although, I admit I've never advocated the Bree=Cassie theories.

nobackspacebutton · Post by **nobackspacebutton** » Mon Jan 15, 2007 3:31 pm

redheaddiva wrote:
milowent wrote:
nobackspacebutton wrote:They aren't gay. The storyline wouldn't work out like that. It just wouldn't.
I have to agree. While it could be an interesting and deep storyline to pursue, lg15 is not going to visit brokeback mountain. I bet we get a few more ambiguous clues of it here and there, just to keep us guessing. I guess Jonas could end up being gay, i think the world can handle that.
What I find really interesting is that so many people are saying "Hey, Jonas must be gay" because:

1. Jonas isn't humping Bree's leg.
2. Jonas and Daniel are becoming friends.

Seriously, is heterosexuality so fragile?

Seriously. Just because he's just trying to pounce Bree, doesn't mean he's not into girls.

I'm sure he's the handsomely shy type. =P

redheaddiva · Post by **redheaddiva** » Mon Jan 15, 2007 3:44 pm

nobackspacebutton wrote:I'm sure he's the handsomely shy type. =P

That's how he is in my fantasies, anyway...

It's my particular weakness, I think. Handsome, shy, into science. Rawr.

And yo, JustAnother... thanks for the enthusastic applause!