What did Jonas see?

[PinkoLady]

Bree says P. Monkey has been around for a while.
As if she has had him/her since she was little

He looks brand new, she didn't even name P. Monkey "P. Monkey" till after the first few videos, and intially referred to P. Monkey as a "she."

I really doubt she meant to imply she had him since she was little.

[Sami]

She said 'P. Monkey has been around for a while' not 'p. monkey is brand new'

no, jk... he/she does look brand new and if she had him/her, she would know his/her gender

[PinkoLady]

Though, she could just be so accepting of the fact that he's transgender, that she doesn't even acknowledge it.

[MintyBeast]

She said 'P. Monkey has been around for a while' not 'p. monkey is brand new'

no, jk... he/she does look brand new and if she had him/her, she would know his/her gender

I've had my cats for years and sometimes I say "she" about the boy. Could have been a slip of the tongue.

[Opladybug]

*nods* I do the same with my dog at times.

[PinkoLady]

I've had my cats for years and sometimes I say "she" about the boy. Could have been a slip of the tongue.

It wasn't a slip of the tongue, watch the video "Purple Monkey."

[Lurker]

Bree says P. Monkey has been around for a while.
As if she has had him/her since she was little

He looks brand new, she didn't even name P. Monkey "P. Monkey" till after the first few videos, and intially referred to P. Monkey as a "she."

Actually, the very second vlog was called "Purple Monkey" (and the shortened version "P. Monkey" was used only three videos later). You're right, though, that she initially referred to him as "she."

I really doubt she meant to imply she had him since she was little.

She did say she'd had him for a while, though. And, really, I don't think we were ever supposed to assume her entire room - minus the Crowley picture - had just recently been furnished by Target.

[PinkoLady]

Haha, yeah, I understand that, but I my point was really that I don't think the Creators would presume to get away with it being some kind of childhood toy that would years later connect Bree and Jonas's path.

It's too new looking, too well-identified as a new thing, and the gender switch is just too... I don't know, uncharacteristic of childhood toy.

[PinkoLady]

Actually, the very second vlog was called "Purple Monkey" (and the shortened version "P. Monkey" was used only three videos later).

But that name came from the rap aspect of the video, and in that second vlog, she has P. Monkey say, "My name is Purple Puppet," which just shows a vagueness and a lack of identity in the odd way P.Monkey had one later.

The "P.Monkey identity" that we saw clearly in later vlogs just seemed to come about too late for her to have P. Monkey since she was little.

Either way, I don't think that whatever Jonas saw has anything to do with P. Monkey.

[jeezy]

Actually, the very second vlog was called "Purple Monkey" (and the shortened version "P. Monkey" was used only three videos later).

But that name came from the rap aspect of the video, and in that second vlog, she has P. Monkey say, "My name is Purple Puppet," which just shows a vagueness and a lack of identity in the odd way P.Monkey had one later.

The "P.Monkey identity" that we saw clearly in later vlogs just seemed to come about too late for her to have P. Monkey since she was little.

Either way, I don't think that whatever Jonas saw has anything to do with P. Monkey.

I agree... but if not P. Monkey then what?!

[Emersion]

Actually, the very second vlog was called "Purple Monkey" (and the shortened version "P. Monkey" was used only three videos later).

But that name came from the rap aspect of the video, and in that second vlog, she has P. Monkey say, "My name is Purple Puppet," which just shows a vagueness and a lack of identity in the odd way P.Monkey had one later.

The "P.Monkey identity" that we saw clearly in later vlogs just seemed to come about too late for her to have P. Monkey since she was little.

Either way, I don't think that whatever Jonas saw has anything to do with P. Monkey.

I agree... but if not P. Monkey then what?!

The thing he was looking at wasn't purple at all!!!!!
The light was purple so when you looked at it... it was purple!!!
When looked at it without the light... it's grey... or green
It's not a picture of alester crowly is it?!?!

[jeezy]

Actually, the very second vlog was called "Purple Monkey" (and the shortened version "P. Monkey" was used only three videos later).

But that name came from the rap aspect of the video, and in that second vlog, she has P. Monkey say, "My name is Purple Puppet," which just shows a vagueness and a lack of identity in the odd way P.Monkey had one later.

The "P.Monkey identity" that we saw clearly in later vlogs just seemed to come about too late for her to have P. Monkey since she was little.

Either way, I don't think that whatever Jonas saw has anything to do with P. Monkey.

I agree... but if not P. Monkey then what?!

The thing he was looking at wasn't purple at all!!!!!
The light was purple so when you looked at it... it was purple!!!
When looked at it without the light... it's grey... or green
It's not a picture of alester crowly is it?!?!

It's gotta be the boxes or that thing... I don't think its a picture though....

[Emersion]

Actually, the very second vlog was called "Purple Monkey" (and the shortened version "P. Monkey" was used only three videos later).

But that name came from the rap aspect of the video, and in that second vlog, she has P. Monkey say, "My name is Purple Puppet," which just shows a vagueness and a lack of identity in the odd way P.Monkey had one later.

The "P.Monkey identity" that we saw clearly in later vlogs just seemed to come about too late for her to have P. Monkey since she was little.

Either way, I don't think that whatever Jonas saw has anything to do with P. Monkey.

I agree... but if not P. Monkey then what?!

The thing he was looking at wasn't purple at all!!!!!
The light was purple so when you looked at it... it was purple!!!
When looked at it without the light... it's grey... or green
It's not a picture of alester crowly is it?!?!

It's gotta be the boxes or that thing... I don't think its a picture though....

Ok maybe it's not a picture.....but
He was definately pointing the light toword that thing/symbol...

[jeezy]

Actually, the very second vlog was called "Purple Monkey" (and the shortened version "P. Monkey" was used only three videos later).

But that name came from the rap aspect of the video, and in that second vlog, she has P. Monkey say, "My name is Purple Puppet," which just shows a vagueness and a lack of identity in the odd way P.Monkey had one later.

The "P.Monkey identity" that we saw clearly in later vlogs just seemed to come about too late for her to have P. Monkey since she was little.

Either way, I don't think that whatever Jonas saw has anything to do with P. Monkey.

I agree... but if not P. Monkey then what?!

The thing he was looking at wasn't purple at all!!!!!
The light was purple so when you looked at it... it was purple!!!
When looked at it without the light... it's grey... or green
It's not a picture of alester crowly is it?!?!

It's gotta be the boxes or that thing... I don't think its a picture though....

Ok maybe it's not a picture.....but
He was definately pointing the light toword that thing/symbol...

What about that rifle thing? or is that just the telescope?

[Emersion]

Actually, the very second vlog was called "Purple Monkey" (and the shortened version "P. Monkey" was used only three videos later).

But that name came from the rap aspect of the video, and in that second vlog, she has P. Monkey say, "My name is Purple Puppet," which just shows a vagueness and a lack of identity in the odd way P.Monkey had one later.

The "P.Monkey identity" that we saw clearly in later vlogs just seemed to come about too late for her to have P. Monkey since she was little.

Either way, I don't think that whatever Jonas saw has anything to do with P. Monkey.

I agree... but if not P. Monkey then what?!

The thing he was looking at wasn't purple at all!!!!!
The light was purple so when you looked at it... it was purple!!!
When looked at it without the light... it's grey... or green
It's not a picture of alester crowly is it?!?!

It's gotta be the boxes or that thing... I don't think its a picture though....

Ok maybe it's not a picture.....but
He was definately pointing the light toword that thing/symbol...

What about that rifle thing? or is that just the telescope?

Hmmm...
The rifle?
Are you sure it's the rifle/telescope?
If he was looking at it he would atleast have a light on it...
Wait it's not a rifle it's a close hanger...(I read in another forum)
Try the thing below it (and that's a maybe)
Do you think the thing above the boxes was a head of someone (like a statue?)