This theory seems pretty shaky to me, and fact-challenged to boot.HyeMew wrote:In my opinion, Cassie being a non-canon spin-off, they decided to do a take off of all of Bree's stuff by having lots of religious-type clues. However, the creators have now revealed Cassie was not religious, in a sense sinking the Cassie creditability. This could be seen as the Creators striking back at all the cassie spin-offs and their heavily occult natures and pulling the stool out from under them.
Seriously, if Cassie is freaked out by tarot and such, why would she leave clues with those very props? The simple answer is because these Cassies are not from the creators themselves and were just using a motif they wanted us to think was related to Cassie too just because they were related to Bree. It seemed like a pretty obvious thing to do at the time, never thinking that the real Cassie was freaked out by it all.
1. We don't know that Cassie is a non-canon spinoff. "This is not a game."
2. Cassie has never employed Tarot cards in her clues. In fact, she has strongly disavowed anything related to Tarot cards (from the widely acknowleged imposter cassies). Strange, HyeMew, that you used to be able to distinguish YTCassie from the others but now you apparently cannot.
3. Bree is the one with a serious credibility problem, not Cassie. Keeping CiW out of it for the moment, Bree's OWN statements about Cassie don't even make sense. Here are Bree's claims about Cassie:
--She used to hang out with Cassie at school, and walked around the track with her.
--She used to hang out with Cassie at home, until there was a disagreement about religion.
--Despite the above, she doesn't remember what Cassie looks like.
This makes no sense whatsoever. It's implausible that Bree would not remember the appearance of her only female friend in the past two years. In fact, it's laughable.
It is also implausible that Daniel, Bree's only male friend, would have never run into Cassie or even heard Bree speak of her. How is this even possible?
It is the LG15 story that has serious internal inconsistencies, not the CiW story. In fact, the only thing that makes sense of the LG15 inconsistencies is Cassie's statement: "Bree tells lies."
This is a strong argument for CiW actually being canon. The LG15 narrative needs CiW to make sense of its own serious gaps of logic.
