Lonelygirl15

Good thinkin. I hope your wrong, I don't want Bree to have mental probs but, nice theory.

Maybe i'm being really dumb.................

but if bree is cassie, how come Daniel never noticed they're the same person?

I don't like the Bree is Cassie theory.. at all

loobylou wrote:Maybe i'm being really dumb.................

but if bree is cassie, how come Daniel never noticed they're the same person?

If this theory is correct, Daniel knows that Bree has an alternate personality named "Cassie". He would know that Bree is herself, but is also comprised of being Cassie, whom expresses her fear of the order and other rebelious behavior.

But, Daniel says he does remember Cassie - how is that possible if her and Bree are the same person?

I dunno, I remember discussing this "back in the day"...but I really don't think so anymore. it doesn't really fit.

This whole "bree is cassie" thing is very interesting. I am trying to grab it all in. The first post on this subject gave me a lot to think about. I think I am going to think a while and get back to you lol meanwhile, the daniel saying that he remembers Cassie really bothers me for some reason ......

i like this theory- and i think the order actually LIKES that bree has split personalities- that if one side doesn't want to do what the order wants, just summon cassie to take over.
so daniel didn't actually remember cassie (she didn't come out that often at school, when bree got real friends *daniel*, she stopped coming out at all), but the order TOLD him to say that

A lot of times when there is ritualistic cults involved, they do program people to dissociate---its one of the qualities they test for at a young age. Those who are not able to dissociate are usually killed or taken care of in some fashion. Dissociation is a cause for Multiple Personality Disorder. Its possible that Bree was taught to Dissociate, which split her mind into seperate egos. One side of her dealt with these issues or was used as a vent for her pain and trauma (cassie) and the other side was completely emotionless to it (bree).