Lonelygirl15

robtomorrow wrote:There is a fundamental problem with this story, the homing pigeon appearing on Madisons door step.

Homing pigeons only return home.

Now Rob, there you go again being, uhm, logical and realistic. Part of me thinks this IS canon because of the logical fallacies. Now, as we know, the c's are sticklers for realism and logic at all times.

Who Released What Pigeon Where?

curiousGeorge wrote:

robtomorrow wrote:There is a fundamental problem with this story, the homing pigeon appearing on Madisons door step.

Homing pigeons only return home.

Now Rob, there you go again being, uhm, logical and realistic. Part of me thinks this IS canon because of the logical fallacies. Now, as we know, the c's are sticklers for realism and logic at all times.

Who Released What Pigeon Where?

Someone dropped the pigeon off at its location.

Maybe it was Adam who homed the pigeon to her doorstep? It seemed to fly into the tree but not further. Or it's a slight suspension of disbelief thing and your arguement is simply nit-picking.

deagol wrote:Maybe it was Adam who homed the pigeon to her doorstep? It seemed to fly into the tree but not further. Or it's a slight suspension of disbelief thing and your arguement is simply nit-picking.

Sorry to nit-pick, but if Adam homed the pigeon then he must know who sent the message.

Besides, he seemed to have no idea where the pigeon came from.

robtomorrow wrote:

deagol wrote:Maybe it was Adam who homed the pigeon to her doorstep? It seemed to fly into the tree but not further. Or it's a slight suspension of disbelief thing and your arguement is simply nit-picking.

Sorry to nit-pick, but if Adam homed the pigeon then he must know who sent the message.

That's what I was implying. It would explain the obvious bad acting.

I'm not saying this is what they're trying to convey though. Just an example of the many ways you can explain the pigeon thing. I just think it's a tiny continuity hole that they wont bother to cover up.

robtomorrow wrote:Besides, he seemed to have no idea where the pigeon came from.

Because he's obviously acting.

Again, not saying that's where the plot is actually going.

there's one other thing i noticed... it shows her watching private videos between the order....(the torture/hypnotism one) Which makes me not believe this is real...

Benjerman wrote:there's one other thing i noticed... it shows her watching private videos between the order....(the torture/hypnotism one) Which makes me not believe this is real...

but still, look at the directing. when they blur, and then focus on certain objects, is like in the lg15 videos.

xjackieee wrote:

Benjerman wrote:there's one other thing i noticed... it shows her watching private videos between the order....(the torture/hypnotism one) Which makes me not believe this is real...

but still, look at the directing. when they blur, and then focus on certain objects, is like in the lg15 videos.

Anyone with the right editing software could do this.

MaddisonAtkinsLiveJournal wrote:Hello, welcome to the Maddison Atkins Live Journal

I created this so we could all collect our info in one place without getting muddled up with the rest of the LG stuff on their forum. If this takes off, I'll create a forum of our own to use.

Maddison isn't canon. Anyone who is canon would not want to move off the LG15 site.

Give it up Rob you are in Phanatical Phanwank land here. Every absurd plot hole and ridiculous logic error can be explained away... Don't argue with them, it is kinda pointless.

colbertnationgirl wrote:

MaddisonAtkinsLiveJournal wrote:Hello, welcome to the Maddison Atkins Live Journal

I created this so we could all collect our info in one place without getting muddled up with the rest of the LG stuff on their forum. If this takes off, I'll create a forum of our own to use.

Maddison isn't canon. Anyone who is canon would not want to move off the LG15 site.

She didn't create that live journal surrealistic pill did to try to handle the amount of stuff that flew at us all at once.

Benjerman wrote:there's one other thing i noticed... it shows her watching private videos between the order....(the torture/hypnotism one) Which makes me not believe this is real...

Yup, there is some dead-horse-flogging on this topic going on over at http://www.lonelygirl15.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=8787 -- I now agree with you that this most likely means MA isn't canon.

Probably not, but it's well integrated, well timed...and good quality. Nothing wrong with that, I suppose.

but... the plot holes! lol I guess they could magically explain them away...