[PUZZLE] Another #1 Dad collage theory.

staticmorning · Post by **staticmorning** » Wed May 30, 2007 11:27 pm

we KNOW she has more then one dad.

her biological father and "mr. bree"
which is where the idea that this may refer to her biological father (first father..) came from

BlackCatonMars · Post by **BlackCatonMars** » Wed May 30, 2007 11:29 pm

cobracommander5 wrote:i just thought about something, having to do with Bree's mom.

wouldn't Bree's mom know that the shots weren't for the order if she was in the order too? at first we thought her dad was giving them too her because the order told him too, but we found out that they were to stop her from being able to complete the ceremony. right?

unless they had her take shots, but her dad switched them...

I'm pretty sure she was supposed to be getting shots but that at some point Bree's dad switched them.

raigne · Post by **raigne** » Wed May 30, 2007 11:41 pm

I don't know if anyone mentioned this yet. But the videos had to be recent. Bree saw the party videos. She was the one who pointed out the photo of Lucy. Don't you think she'd have recognized Sonia and Carl if she'd met them before?

I do, however, think it's plausible that she could have placed the collage there recently. What if the order brought her there after she went to them and the Boston thing is a red herring?

ApotheosisAZ · Post by **ApotheosisAZ** » Thu May 31, 2007 12:12 am

raigne wrote:I don't know if anyone mentioned this yet. But the videos had to be recent. Bree saw the party videos. She was the one who pointed out the photo of Lucy. Don't you think she'd have recognized Sonia and Carl if she'd met them before?

She might, if she wasn't drugged or hypnotized when she made the HoO vids.

EDIT TO ADD: Apo's crazy theory lives on!

raigne · Post by **raigne** » Thu May 31, 2007 12:14 am

They didn't really have to drug her then though, did they? I mean she was still buying into the whole thing hook, line and sinker.

Though, now that you mention it. She did mention being hazy and tired after getting her injections, didn't she?

SARAHPHOBIA88 · Post by **SARAHPHOBIA88** » Thu May 31, 2007 12:14 am

ApotheosisAZ wrote:
raigne wrote:I don't know if anyone mentioned this yet. But the videos had to be recent. Bree saw the party videos. She was the one who pointed out the photo of Lucy. Don't you think she'd have recognized Sonia and Carl if she'd met them before?
She might, if she wasn't drugged or hypnotized when she made the HoO vids.

EDIT TO ADD: Apo's crazy theory lives on!

Bree could just be playing along! Can't wait to find out!

ApotheosisAZ · Post by **ApotheosisAZ** » Thu May 31, 2007 12:39 am

No, Bree isn't just playing along.

My theory is that we haven't seen Bree since she left with Lucy.

The Order just wants us to think we are seeing recent videos of her.

Hannahbee · Post by **Hannahbee** » Thu May 31, 2007 12:40 am

well i have to say, the picture of Bree pointing totally stands out to me- it's like back when we used to watch Sesame Street: "one of these things is not like the others, one of these things just doesn't belong..." etc.

if they ARE glued on, i would be tempted to take that photo off and look under it. the background is the harshest, her eyes are muuuch wider than in any of the others, and it was clearly put on last even IF it WAS there originally. i mean, for all we know, Bree's dad made this to hide another secret, right? i'm definitely rooting for looking behind the pictures if it's possible. thoughts?

raigne · Post by **raigne** » Thu May 31, 2007 12:44 am

Something behind is an interesting thought... perhaps we should ask D&J how the pictures are attatched?

SARAHPHOBIA88 · Post by **SARAHPHOBIA88** » Thu May 31, 2007 12:47 am

ApotheosisAZ wrote:No, Bree isn't just playing along.

My theory is that we haven't seen Bree since she left with Lucy.

The Order just wants us to think we are seeing recent videos of her.

Oh! Wow! Cool!

Gidget · Post by **Gidget** » Thu May 31, 2007 1:15 am

BrightSilence wrote:I agree with Inigo. I do like the idea that maybe the pictures were made recently. Maybe Bree is near the campsite, there were clearly others there. She might have found out about the CAMP PLAY message before and figured DB an Jonas would go look for the box, and have decided to put another hint in there.

Just to play devils advocate:
If she was able to take photos of herself, and then sneak away and hide them as a code, couldn't she just put a big note that says "Hey Daniel and Jonas, this is whats up?" inside the box instead?

I know I'm debunking my own theory here, but oh well. It just came to mind. Unless there is a different purpose for her leaving it there.

raigne wrote:I don't know if anyone mentioned this yet. But the videos had to be recent. Bree saw the party videos. She was the one who pointed out the photo of Lucy. Don't you think she'd have recognized Sonia and Carl if she'd met them before?

Touché. Good point.

angie_pants · Post by **angie_pants** » Thu May 31, 2007 3:58 am

i like this theory, the only problem i have with it is that if these videos were filmed before, then what about the messages in them? either whatever they were meant to protect against passed, or the secret messages weren't really there and they dont mean anything at all.

and i'm holding hope that something will happen on friday!

ApotheosisAZ · Post by **ApotheosisAZ** » Thu May 31, 2007 4:22 am

Well, if these secret messages are directed at someone in the resistance, then this does kill my crazy theory.

However, if they are coded Order messages, then it doesn't.

The crazy theory survives until Friday!!!

RedRevolver · Post by **RedRevolver** » Thu May 31, 2007 5:29 am

ApotheosisAZ wrote:No, Bree isn't just playing along.

My theory is that we haven't seen Bree since she left with Lucy.

The Order just wants us to think we are seeing recent videos of her.

If this is true, then the coded messages wouldn't work.

And the coded messages have been (somewhat) confirmed.

ApotheosisAZ · Post by **ApotheosisAZ** » Thu May 31, 2007 5:58 am

RedRevolver wrote:
If this is true, then the coded messages wouldn't work.

And the coded messages have been (somewhat) confirmed.

You mean confirmed by Taylor, right?

That is a valid source of info, but it still doesn't show that the coded messages aren't Order messages.

Apo's crazy theory still alive until Friday.