Living In London - Gemmers19

spaciegirlreturn · Post by **spaciegirlreturn** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 3:43 pm

colbertnationgirl wrote:i realize that this is fanfic. but shouldn't it be in a different catagory? this catagory is for actual lonelygirl15 or danielbeast videos.

Everyone seems pretty sure that this is part of lonelygirl15, that's why it's here.....and the fact that it hasn't been moved may be a confirmation.

DontHaveAClue · Post by **DontHaveAClue** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 3:43 pm

robtomorrow wrote:Saying someone deserves to be put down like a dog, ( killed) for expressing an opinion is deserving of respect?

No. But no one said Bree's mother deserve any respect, beside having a good looking daughter. I guess it's a way to indicate Bree's mother was already nuts back then.

robtomorrow · Post by **robtomorrow** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 3:44 pm

iamcool wrote:
robtomorrow wrote:Saying someone deserves to be put down like a dog, ( killed) for expressing an opinion is deserving of respect? Its sounds more like Islamo-facisism (to use Rummies term) to me.

erm, what?

WHat? What didn't you understand? I'll try to explain it better.

DontHaveAClue · Post by **DontHaveAClue** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 3:46 pm

colbertnationgirl wrote:i realize that this is fanfic. but shouldn't it be in a different catagory? this catagory is for actual lonelygirl15 or danielbeast videos.

catagory? is that a category for catastrophic gory events?

oups sorry, was mean. But you are right, this thread should be displaced in the fanfic section very soon. Then it will come back here after it's officially recognized as canon. We like to keep our mods busy.

laurenesque · Post by **laurenesque** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 3:50 pm

spaciegirl wrote:
colbertnationgirl wrote:i realize that this is fanfic. but shouldn't it be in a different catagory? this catagory is for actual lonelygirl15 or danielbeast videos.
Everyone seems pretty sure that this is part of lonelygirl15, that's why it's here.....and the fact that it hasn't been moved may be a confirmation.

Moved. Ah well.

iamcool · Post by **iamcool** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 4:09 pm

robtomorrow wrote:
iamcool wrote:
robtomorrow wrote:Saying someone deserves to be put down like a dog, ( killed) for expressing an opinion is deserving of respect? Its sounds more like Islamo-facisism (to use Rummies term) to me.

erm, what?
WHat? What didn't you understand? I'll try to explain it better.

everything lol

iamcool · Post by **iamcool** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 4:11 pm

on her myspace it says she lives in the united kingdom, but people who live in the uk dont say they live in the uk, they say "i'm from scotland" or "i'm from england" ..... and there are people who live in L.A saying i will see u in school and stuff. sooooo why do u think she put she lives in the uk on her profile? lol

p.s sorry if i'm being to sherlock homesish, i'm just wonderin lol

Reb · Post by **Reb** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 4:16 pm

iamcool wrote:on her myspace it says she lives in the united kingdom, but people who live in the uk dont say they live in the uk, they say "i'm from scotland" or "i'm from england" ..... and there are people who live in L.A saying i will see u in school and stuff. sooooo why do u think she put she lives in the uk on her profile? lol

p.s sorry if i'm being to sherlock homesish, i'm just wonderin lol

Not necissarly true I will either say I am from the UK or London I rarely say I am from England.

iamcool · Post by **iamcool** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 4:19 pm

no if someone says where do u live, most people would say england not the uk, coz if u sed uk .... people might think your from wales

omegawoman · Post by **omegawoman** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 4:21 pm

I think Gemma is warning Bree about her mother still being highly respected- as in "watch what you say and to who". If Bree confinds in her mother for instance, it could get back to Gemma's mother, who is a big part of the "community"

Reb · Post by **Reb** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 4:26 pm

iamcool wrote:no if someone says where do u live, most people would say england not the uk, coz if u sed uk .... people might think your from wales

If someone asks where I am from when I am in another country then I will say the UK if someone in the UK asks me where I am from I will say London! I should maybe reconsider that as I don't want people to think that I am welsh

Sfonzarelli · Post by **Sfonzarelli** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 5:21 pm

SharpI wrote:Bree's mom is a staunch believer, to the point that skeptics should be put down like dogs. Eeek.

robtomorrow wrote:Saying someone deserves to be put down like a dog, ( killed) for expressing an opinion is deserving of respect? Its sounds more like Islamo-facisism (to use Rummies term) to me.

DontHaveAClue wrote:it's a way to indicate Bree's mother was already nuts back then.

Except if you actually listened to the video, she said nothing remotely related to what you guys are talking about. What she said was:

Bree's Mom wrote:Any bloke who's business it was to thwart the right of an individual should be put down to sleep like a dog

Sorry to start a flame war, but I agree with that statement 100 percent.

Also, why are you guys assuming that this girl has fallen out of grace with her religion? Has she given any indication of that? She just no longer lives in whatever community Bree and her parents lived in when they were in Nottinghamshire. (To be technical, Bree said that her "commune" was in New Zealand - either they moved from a commune in New Zealand to another commune in Nottinghamshire, where they met Gemma, or both Bree's family and Gemma's family moved from a commune in New Zealand to Nottinghamshire, which is doubtful) Also, the commune does not equal "The Order of Denderah", which does not equal Bree's religion. Just because she doesn't live in the commune any more, doesn't mean she's not a member of this religion. That's like saying when a Catholic moves away from their town of birth, they're no longer a Catholic because they don't go to the exact same church. And the Order of Denderah is probably just a specific sub-organization or rank or something in her religious organization, or perhaps a religious structure that exists within her unstructured faith. It probably has nothing to do with the commune, unless all of the people at Bree's ceremony were vacationing from Britian.

You know what's odd? That wherever she used to live would have somehow sheltered her from Thai food. It makes no sense. Aleister Crowley loved Asian shit.

HenrySugar · Post by **HenrySugar** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 6:20 pm

I found it odd that she didn't like Thai food...

robtomorrow · Post by **robtomorrow** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 6:44 pm

Sfonzarelli

"Any bloke who's business it was to thwart the right of an individual should be put down to sleep like a dog" IS a better transcription of what Gemma quoted Bree's mother having said.

But I guess I'm reading between the lines, because the context was a lecture by an atheist philosophy professor at a university. And it still sounds like Islamo-facism to me, or to paraphrase Rummies term Thelemo-facism.

Sfonzarelli · Post by **Sfonzarelli** » Sun Oct 22, 2006 6:48 pm

robtomorrow wrote:But I guess I'm reading between the lines, because the context was a lecture by an atheist philosophy professor at a university. And it still sounds like Islamo-facism to me, or to paraphrase Rummies term Thelemo-facism.

I suspect that's your own bias against religion. Why aren't you assuming whoever she's adressing wasn't an "atheisto-fascist"? (As in, every other atheist I've ever met)

What she's advocating is the EXACT OPPOSITE of fascism.